Is Changing an SEO Agency Something I Should Be Afraid of?
TL;DR Ending a contract with an SEO agency raises understandable fears: will rankings drop, will traffic fall, will backlinks disappear? These things can happen, but most of them can be prevented. Having worked on both sides, losing clients to other agencies and ending contracts with agencies as a client, here is what we check to […]
TL;DR
- Changing agencies is safe if you own your accounts and data and plan the handover.
- The real risks: lost access, lost history, links from the old agency’s own sites, and a new strategy that drops pages which were quietly bringing traffic.
- Before you switch: check ownership of Search Console, GA4, Tag Manager, Merchant Center and the CMS, export data, audit backlinks and record a baseline of rankings, traffic, conversions and AI visibility.
- Give the new agency full history from the start, and don’t redesign the site in the same quarter.
Ending a contract with an SEO agency raises understandable fears: will rankings drop, will traffic fall, will backlinks disappear? These things can happen, but most of them can be prevented. Having worked on both sides, losing clients to other agencies and ending contracts with agencies as a client, here is what we check to make the switch safe.
Why do companies change SEO agencies?
- Results: traffic, leads or sales don’t match expectations or the agency can’t explain them.
- Communication: reports without conclusions, slow responses, no clear plan.
- Business changes: a new decision-maker, a new strategy, new markets.
- Scope: the company needs skills the agency doesn’t have, for example analytics or AI search visibility.
If you’re still deciding whether an agency is right for you at all, see why it’s worth hiring an SEO agency and Google’s advice on hiring an SEO.
Make your brand visible – from Google to AI chatbots.
What can go wrong when you change SEO agencies?
| Risk | Why it happens | How to prevent it |
|---|---|---|
| Rankings drop | The new agency changes priorities or needs time to learn the site | Share ranking history; agree to keep pages that bring traffic |
| Traffic drops | Content or pages maintained by the old agency are dropped or changed | Inventory pages with organic traffic before changing anything |
| Traffic quality drops | The new strategy targets broader keywords that convert worse | Share conversion data per page and keyword group |
| Backlinks disappear | Links from the old agency’s own sites are removed | Audit backlinks before the switch and assess the real impact |
| Lost access and history | Accounts were set up and owned by the agency | Make sure the company owns every account; export data |
What should you secure before switching?
Accounts and access
Your company, not the agency, should be the owner of every account. In Search Console, check that a person from your company is a verified owner and remove the old agency’s users after the handover (Google).
| Account or asset | Check |
|---|---|
| Google Search Console (all properties) | Owner from your company; list of users |
| Google Analytics 4 and Google Tag Manager | Admin rights for your company; documentation of tags and key events |
| Merchant Center, Google Ads, Bing Webmaster Tools | Ownership and admin access |
| CMS, hosting, domain registrar, CDN | Admin accounts in your name; who has server access |
| Rank tracking and SEO tools | Export project data; the agency’s tools stay with the agency |
| Content and reports | Contract confirms you own the content, audits and reports |
Data and history
Search Console keeps 16 months of performance data, and GA4 keeps event-level data for explorations for only 2 or 14 months, depending on your settings (Google). Export what you need, or set up the Search Console bulk export and GA4 export to BigQuery so history stays with you (Google, GA4 + BigQuery costs).
A baseline to compare against
- Rankings for key phrases and the pages that rank for them.
- Organic sessions, engagement rate, conversions and revenue per landing page (last 12–16 months).
- Click-through rate per page in Search Console: high rankings with low traffic mean an opportunity, not a success.
- Number of referring domains and the most valuable links.
- How often AI assistants (ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews) mention your brand for key questions; mentions on other sites drive this (Ahrefs).
How do you check the risk to your backlinks?
Fear of losing backlinks is the most common one, often after a bad experience. Some agencies place clients’ links on their own sites and remove them when the contract ends. An audit shows how much of your visibility actually depends on them.
- Export all backlinks from a tool such as Ahrefs or Semrush, and from Search Console’s Links report.
- Group them by source: earned (press, quotes, natural mentions), sponsored articles and guest posts, and sites run by the agency.
- Mark the risk: earned links are stable; sponsored articles usually stay; links from the agency’s sites are likely to disappear.
- Assess the impact: which pages and keywords those links support, and how much traffic those pages bring.
- Plan the response: if low-quality agency links disappear, rankings rarely suffer. If valuable ones go, earn replacements through content, digital PR and partnerships.
Don’t try to rebuild the old profile one-to-one with the same anchor texts. Networks of sites built for links and patterns of exact-match anchors break Google’s spam policies (Google), and paid links should be marked rel=”sponsored” (Google). Links still matter, but brand mentions on trusted sites matter more for AI visibility (backlinks in AI search).
Let your customers find you, wherever they look.
What should the new agency do in the first 90 days?
| Period | Actions |
|---|---|
| Before the start | Access, data exports, backlink audit, baseline; handover meeting with the old agency if possible |
| Weeks 1–4 | Technical audit and analytics audit; list of pages that bring organic traffic and conversions; no major changes yet |
| Weeks 5–8 | Strategy based on data: quick wins (CTR, internal linking, content updates); plan for links and brand mentions |
| Weeks 9–12 | First changes live; monthly report against the baseline; adjust priorities |
Avoid changing the agency and redesigning or migrating the site at the same time: if results drop, you won’t know why. SEO results build over time; see why one-off optimization doesn’t last.
FAQ
Will I lose rankings if I change my SEO agency?
Not if you keep the pages, content and links that bring traffic and give the new agency full history. Short fluctuations happen; lasting drops usually come from lost links or changes to key pages.
Can my old agency remove my backlinks?
Only links on sites it controls. An audit before the switch shows how many there are and how much they matter.
Who owns my Search Console and Analytics accounts?
Whoever is set as owner or admin. Check it before you end the contract and make sure your company holds the top level of access.
How long before a new agency shows results?
Expect the first effects of changes in 2–3 months and a clear trend in 6–12 months, depending on competition and the state of the site.
Sources
- Google Search Central: Do you need an SEO?
- Google Search Central: Spam policies – link spam
- Google Search Central: Qualify your outbound links
- Search Console Help: Managing owners, users and permissions
- Google Search Central Blog: Bulk data export
- Analytics Help: Data retention and Engagement rate and bounce rate
- Ahrefs: AI brand visibility correlations
About the author: This article was prepared by the Insightland SEO and GEO team. Insightland is a Wrocław-based agency, part of the Hexe Capital Tech Hub, that connects business, tech and data: SEO and GEO, performance marketing, UX and analytics, and SEO and AI training. Contact us.